Search Afterall.net

 
Search  All Papers Clippings Illogic Books Quotes

Register new account

Request new password

 
RSS
History and Method and A and not A
All > Categories > Origins & Science > Philosophy of Science (27)
All > Categories > Worldviews > Postmodernism > Relativism & Pluralism (30)
Any of these categories
Richard Dawkins on Science said...
"Hall of Mirrors", in Forbes ASAP, October 2, 2000.
Is it just our Western scientific bias to be impressed by accurate prediction, to be impressed by the power to sling rockets around Jupiter to reach Saturn, or intercept and repair the Hubble telescope, to be impressed by logic itself? Well, let's concede the point and think sociologically, even democratically. Suppose we agree, temporarily, to treat scientific truth as just one truth among many, and lay it alongside all the rival contenders: Trobriand truth, Kikuyu truth, Maori truth, Inuit truth, Navajo truth, Yanomamo truth, !Kung San truth, feminist truth, Islamic truth, Hindu truth. The list is endless — and thereby hangs a revealing observation. In theory, people could switch allegiance from any one "truth" to any other if they decided it had greater merit. On what basis might they do so? Why would one change from, say, Kikuyu truth to Navajo truth? Such merit-driven switches are rare — with one crucially important exception: switches to scientific truth from any of the others. Scientific truth is the only member of this endless list that evidentially convinces converts of its superiority. People are loyal to other belief systems because they were brought up that way, and they have never known anything better. When people are lucky enough to be offered the opportunity to vote with their feet, doctors prosper and shamans decline. Even those who do not, or cannot, avail themselves of a scientific education choose to benefit from technology made possible by the scientific education of others.
 
About Afterall.net Contact Afterall.net

Browse in Articles

  • Categories (1138)
    • Metaphysics (30)
    • Epistemology (61)
    • Aesthetics (18)
    • Being Human (102)
    • Christianity (84)
    • Ethics (98)
    • Faith and Reason (135)
    • Jesus (54)
    • Origins & Science (150)
    • Religion (62)
    • Skepticism (36)
    • Society & Culture (81)
    • A/Theism (99)
    • Truth (18)
    • Worldviews (110)

Translator

  • Nederlands
  • Français
  • Português
  • Español
  • Deutsch
  • 한국어
  • 中文 (简体)
  • Русский

Popular in Books

  • Rhetoric or Reason
  • How People Poison Everything
  • Is Goodness without God Good Enough?
  • Reasonable Faith: Christian Truth and Apologetics
  • What Is a "Scientific Fact"? Won't Plain Ol' Facts Do?
  • There Is a God
  • The Persecuted Atheist?
  • The Victory of Reason
  • Missing the Point
  • The Jesus Legend

Popular in Quotes

  • Lt. Col. Mervin Willett Gonin DSO on the Holocaust
  • Thomas Reid on Knowing Thyself
  • Bill Maher on Religious Certitude
  • Edward R. Murrow on Truth
  • Stephen Jay Gould on Scientific Presuppositions
  • J.P. Moreland on Rival Worldviews
  • Camilla Paglia on Art
  • J.P. Moreland on Postmodernism and Anger
  • Angus Menuge on Inference to the Best Explanation
  • Pope Benedict XVI on the Meaning of Evolve

Popular in Papers

  • Philosophical Apologetics, the Church, and Contemporary Culture
  • Is Science a Threat or Help to Faith?
  • Aquinas versus Locke and Descartes on the Human Person and End-of-Life Ethics
  • Complementarity, Agency Theory, and the God-of-the-Gaps
  • The Euthanasia Debate: Understanding the Issues
  • Argument from Consciousness
  • Naturalism and Libertarian Agency
  • What Is Naturalism that We Should Be Mindful of It?
  • The Experiential Basis of Theism
  • Miracles and Justified Belief: Further Clarification

Random

  • C.S. Lewis on Ethics and Christianity
  • Vincent van Gogh on Love
  • Division
  • Affirming the Consequent
  • Vincent van Gogh on God
  • Bertrand Russell on Creation
  • The Evidential Argument from Evil
  • Lao-tzu on Being a Great Power
  • Francis A. Schaeffer on Anti-Intellectualism
  • The Euthanasia Debate: Assessing the Options