RSS
Ethical Systems and Paper Trails
David Basinger
Theists frequently argue that nontheists must affirm the following:
(1) If there is no God, each person must define "good" and "evil"
for herself. (2) If each person must define "good" and "evil"
for herself, there can be no objective moral standard. (3) God
does not exist. (4) Therefore there can be no objective moral
standard (i.e., all moral principles are relative). Some nontheists agree (e.g., Sartre) and attempt to live with
the implications of (4). Others deny (2), claiming that the existence
of an objective moral standard is not dependent on religious commitment.
Kai Nielsen is one of the best known and most outspoken members
of this group. Nielsen argued that "the nonexistence of God does
not preclude the possibility of there being an objective standard
on which to base [moral] judgments." He has recently reaffirmed
this claim:

