The Abortion Controversy (second edition) is a superb anthology in
which all the major viewpoints on abortion are well represented. Highlights
include Michael Tooley's latest formulation of his argument against
foetal personhood, Judith Jarvis Thomson's classic "A Defense of
Abortion", David Boonin-Vail's brilliant 1997 defense of what he calls
the "Responsibility Objection" to Thomson's argument, and Keith
Pavlischek's interesting 1998 critique of Thomson and Boonin-Vail.
Pavlischek essentially admits that Boonin-Vail's arguments succeed, but
points out (correctly, I think) that those arguments entail that if a
woman becomes pregnant to a man who wishes to play no part in the
child's life, then that man, the father, is not morally obliged to pay
child-support to the mother. Pavlischek thinks that many pro-choicers
would find this implication unacceptable. I would add that on the other
hand, many pro-choicers would regard this implication as perfectly
just, so that Boonin-Vail's defense of Thomson is (for them at least)
ultima facie sound. These are just some of the interesting
issues covered in the book; there are many more. Since no other
anthology is as wide-ranging, up-to-date and authoritative as this one,
"The Abortion Controversy" is essential reading for anyone who is
interested in the philosophical debate over abortion. ~
Dean Stretton at Amazon.com