Quentin Smith on Philosophical Theism
"The Metaphilosophy of Naturalism", Philo 4/2 (2001)
Naturalists passively watched as realist versions of theism, most influenced by Plantinga's writings, began to sweep through the philosophical community, until today perhaps one-quarter or one-third of philosophy professors are theists, with most being orthodox Christians. Although many theists do not work in the area of the philosophy of religion, so many of them do work in this area that there are now over five philosophy journals devoted to theism or the philosophy of religion, such as Faith and Philosophy, Religious Studies, International Journal of the Philosophy of Religion, Sophia, Philosophia Christi, etc. Philosophia Christi began in the late 1990s and already is overflowing with submissions from leading philosophers. If each naturalist who does not specialize in the philosophy of
religion (i.e., over ninety-nine percent of naturalists) were locked in
a room with theists who do specialize in the philosophy of religion,
and if the ensuing debates were refereed by a naturalist who had a
specialization in the philosophy of religion, the naturalist referee
could at most hope the outcome would be that 'no definite conclusion
can be drawn regarding the rationality of faith,' although I expect the
most probable outcome is that the naturalist, wanting to be a fair and
objective referee, would have to conclude that the theists definitely
had the upperhand in every single argument or debate. God is not "dead"
in academia; he returned to life in the late 1960s and is now alive and
well in his last academic stronghold, philosophy departments.
Filed in...

Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.
Lest they devolve into the infantile comments on display at YouTube and elsewhere, comments require registration and are moderated, not for point of view but for quality. » Register or » Login