Consider all. Test All. Hold on to the good.
Knowledge and Its Limits
Timothy Williamson (Oxford University Press: Dec 2002), 352 pages.
Table of Contents
-
- Introduction 1
- 1 Knowing and acting 1
- 2 Unanalysable knowledge 2
- 3 Factive mental states 5
- 4 Knowledge as the justification of belief and assertion 8
- 5 The myth of epistemic transparency 11
- 6 Unknowable truths 18
- 1 A State of Mind 21
- 1.1 Factive attitudes 21
- 1.2 Mental states, first-person accessibility, and scepticism 23
- 1.3 Knowledge and analysis 27
- 1.4 Knowing as the most general factive mental state 33
- 1.5 Knowing and believing 41
- 2 Broadness 49
- 2.1 Internalism and externalism 49
- 2.2 Broad and narrow conditions 51
- 2.3 Mental differences between knowing and believing 54
- 2.4 The causal efficacy of knowledge 60
- 3 Primeness 65
- 3.1 Prime and composite conditions 65
- 3.2 Arguments for primeness 66
- 3.3 Free recombination 73
- 3.4 The explanatory value of prime conditions 75
- 3.5 The value of generality 80
- 3.6 Explanation and correlation coefficients 83
- 3.7 Primeness and the causal order 88
- 3.8 Non-conjunctive decompositions 89
- 4 Anti-Luminosity 93
- 4.1 Cognitive homes 93
- 4.2 Luminosity 94
- 4.3 An argument against luminosity 96
- 4.4 Reliability 98
- 4.5 Sorites arguments 102
- 4.6 Generalizations 106
- 4.7 Scientific tests 109
- 4.8 Assertibility conditions 110
- 5 Margins and Iterations 114
- 5.1 Knowing that one knows 114
- 5.2 Further iterations 120
- 5.3 Close possibilities 123
- 5.4 Point estimates 130
- 5.5 Iterated interpersonal knowledge 131
- 6 An Application 135
- 6.1 Surprise Examinations 135
- 6.2 Conditionally Unexpected Examinations 143
- 7 Sensitivity 147
- 7.1 Preview 147
- 7.2 Counterfactual sensitivity 148
- 7.3 Counterfactuals and scepticism 150
- 7.4 Methods 152
- 7.5 Contextualist sensitivity 156
- 7.6 Sensitivity and broad content 161
- 8 Scepticism 164
- 8.1 Plan 164
- 8.2 Scepticism and the non-symmetry of epistemic accessibility 164
- 8.3 Difference of evidence in good and bad cases 169
- 8.4 An argument for sameness of evidence 170
- 8.5 The phenomenal conception of evidence 173
- 8.6 Sameness of evidence and the sorites 174
- 8.7 The non-transparency of rationality 178
- 8.8 Scepticism without sameness of evidence 181
- 9 Evidence 184
- 9.1 Knowledge as justifying belief 184
- 9.2 Bodies of evidence 186
- 9.3 Access to evidence 190
- 9.4 An argument 193
- 9.5 Evidence as propositional 194
- 9.6 Propositional evidence as knowledge 200
- 9.7 Knowledge as evidence 203
- 9.8 Non-pragmatic justification 207
- 10 Evidential Probability 209
- 10.1 Vague probability 209
- 10.2 Uncertain evidence 213
- 10.3 Evidence and knowledge 221
- 10.4 Epistemic accessibility 224
- 10.5 A simple model 228
- 10.6 A puzzling phenomenon 230
- 11 Assertion 238
- 11.1 Rules of assertion 238
- 11.2 The truth account 244
- 11.3 The knowledge account 249
- 11.4 Objections to the knowledge account, and replies 255
- 11.5 The BK and RBK accounts 260
- 11.6 Mathematical assertions 263
- 11.7 The point of assertion 266
- 12 Structural Unknowability 270
- 12.1 Fitch’s argument 270
- 12.2 Distribution over conjunction 275
- 12.3 Quantification into sentence position 285
- 12.4 Unanswerable questions 289
- 12.5 Trans-world knowability 290
- Appendix 1 Correlation Coefficients 302
- Appendix 2 Counting Iterations of Knowledge 305
- Appendix 3 A Formal Model of Slight Insensitivity Almost Everywhere 307
- Appendix 4 Iterated Probabilities in Epistemic Logic (Proofs) 311
- Appendix 5 A Non-Symmetric Epistemic Model 316
- Appendix 6 Distribution over Conjunction 318
- Bibliography 321
- Index 333