In Defense of Natural Law
Robert P. George (Oxford University Press: April 2001), 360 pages.In Making Men Moral, his 1995 book, Robert George questioned the central doctrines of liberal jurisprudence and political theory. In his new work he extends his critique of liberalism and goes beyond it to show how contemporary natural law theory provides a superior way of thinking about basic problems of justice and poltical morality. It is written with the same combination of stylistic elegance and analytical rigor that distinguishes his critical work. Not content merely to defend natural law against its cultural critics, he deftly turns the tables and deploys the idea to mount a stunning attack on predominant liberal beliefs about such issues as abortion, sexuality, and the place of religion in public life. Readers interested in law, political science, and philosophy will find George’s arguments both challenging and compelling. ~ Product Description
Table of Contents
-
- Introduction 1
- Pt. 1 Theoretical Issues 15
- 1 A Defense of the New Natural Law Theory 17
- 2 Recent Criticism of Natural Law Theory 31
- 3 Natural Law and Human Nature 83
- 4 Does the ‘Incommensurability Thesis’ Imperil Common Sense Moral Judgments? 92
- 5 Natural Law and Positive Law 102
- 6 Free Choice, Practical Reason and Fitness for the Rule of Law 113
- Pt. 2 Moral and Political Questions 123
- 7 Religious Liberty and Political Morality 125
- 8 Marriage and the Liberal Imagination 139
- 9 What Sex Can Be: Alienation, Illusion or One-Flesh Union 161
- 10 Making Children Moral: Pornography, Parents and the Public Interest 184
- 11 Public Reason and Political Conflict: Abortion and Homosexuality 196
- 12 Natural Law and International Order 228
- Pt. 3 Dialectical Engagement 247
- 13 Moral Particularism, Thomism and Traditions 249
- 14 Human Flourishing as a Criterion of Morality: A Critique of Perry’s Naturalism 259
- 15 Nature, Morality and Homosexuality 276
- 16 Can Sex Be Reasonable? 287
- 17 Moralistic Liberalism and Legal Moralism 300
- 18 Law, Democracy and Moral Disagreement 315
- Index 335