Illogic Primer Quotes Clippings Books and Bibliography Paper Trails Links Film

Wandering in Darkness

Eleonore Stump (Oxford University Press: November 9, 2012), 688 pages.

Only the most naive or tendentious among us would deny the extent and intensity of suffering in the world. Can one hold, consistently with the common view of suffering in the world, that there is an omniscient, omnipotent, perfectly good God? This book argues that one can. Wandering in Darkness first presents the moral psychology and value theory within which one typical traditional theodicy, namely, that of Thomas Aquinas, is embedded. It explicates Aquinas’s account of the good for human beings, including the nature of love and union among persons. Eleonore Stump also makes use of developments in neurobiology and developmental psychology to illuminate the nature of such union. Stump then turns to an examination of narratives. In a methodological section focused on epistemological issues, the book uses recent research involving autism spectrum disorder to argue that some philosophical problems are best considered in the context of narratives. Using the methodology argued for, the book gives detailed, innovative exegeses of the stories of Job, Samson, Abraham and Isaac, and Mary of Bethany. In the context of these stories and against the backdrop of Aquinas’s other views, Stump presents Aquinas’s own theodicy, and shows that Aquinas’s theodicy gives a powerful explanation for God’s allowing suffering. She concludes by arguing that this explanation constitutes a consistent and cogent defense for the problem of suffering.

Table of Contents

  • Incipit
  • Part I: The Nature of the Project
    • 1. Suffering, Theodicy, and Defense
    • 2. Philosophy and Narrative
    • 3. Narrative as a Means of Knowledge: Francis and Dominic
    • 4. Narrative and the Knowledge of Persons
  • Part II: The World at Large: Love and Loneliness
    • 5. The Nature of Love
    • 6. Union, Presence, and Omnipresence
    • 7. Willed Loneliness
    • 8. Other-worldly Redemption
  • Part III: The World of the Stories: Suffering in Particular
    • 9. The Story of Job: Suffering and the Second-personal
    • 10. The Story of Samson: Self-Destroying Evil
    • 11. The Story of Abraham: The Desires of the Heart
    • 12. The Story of Mary of Bethany: Heartbrokenness and Shame
  • Part IV: Other-worldly Theodicy: What We Care About in a Defense
    • 13. Theodicy in Another World
    • 14. What We Care About: the Desires of the Heart
    • 15. The Defense of the Defense: Suffering, Flourishing, and the Desires of the Heart
  • Desinit